Best eyeliner for pin up make-up?

[Shelley Minson]

Hi dolls

I am after a new black liquid eye-liner and I thought you might be able to recommend what your favourite eye-liner is for doing the cat eye look?

Thank you : )

 

[Ellie Retrophilia]

I am a budget-conscious gal so I use Physician's Formula cream liner and Hard Candy Hot Smudge.  A cream liner has more control over the line than say a liquid liner as you apply with a brush separate from the liner itself.  A good liquid liner that won't budge if you're looking for an all day type of thing is Milani's Infiniti liquid eye liner.  Does not budge even at your sweatiest. 

[Shelley Minson]

Thank you very much for the tips Ellie. I will check them products out : )

[Ellie Retrophilia]

Also check out Maybelline's cream/gel liner.  The Studio line.  Those are great too. 

[Elise L'amour]

ii use MAC's BlackTrack Fluidline. ii know it's not a liquid eyeliner.. it's a gel liner.. but it's the best eye liner ii've ever used as dar as staying power & intensity & ii usually do a simple pin-up makeup look everyday, when ii'm not wear crazy, bright makeup colours lol. ii use the MAC 210 brush to apply the eyeliner.
but if you really want just a liquid eyeliner, then ii suggest L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Precision Waterproof Eyeliner in Carbon Black. it's pretty swell. It has a slanted felt tip & ii find it easy to use to create that pretty cat eye look. =]

[Roxy Tart {PL Team / Comm. Mgr}]

For gel I love MAC fluidline, and for liquid my go-to for years has been Lancome. But the other day I was in Sephora and decided to try something new. The girl I was talking to (who had perfect pin up make up on) suggested Stila, Stay all day Waterproof liner. I LOVE IT!! It's my new fav hands down.

[Shelley Minson]

Thank you so much to you all for taking the time to respond : ) I have made up a list of all the products, now it is time to go shopping! Thanks again xox

[Sugar Lily Accessories]

MAC's fluid line in "blacktrack" is my favorite eye liner. It stays in place once applied and is great for all day wear. I use it to create the cat eye look and everything in between, I highly recommend it!

[Shelley Minson]

Great thank you, it sounds like MAC's blacktrack fluidline is the overall winner, looking forward to trying it out!  : )

[Bettie Flask Photography]

as long as its black, liquid and a small brush everything I've ever tried has worked for me think I'm using somethin by covergirl but who knows II tend to switch up alot haha

 

[Krystal Duncanson]

I'm with the other girls M.A.C Blacktrack fluidline. However I use sigma brushes cheaper alternative to M.A.C but same quality :)

[Nikki Napalm]

My vote is for MAC Blacktrack Fluidline eyeliner <3

[Shelley Minson]

Thanks gals for your help : )