Best eyeliner for pin up make-up?

[Shelley Minson]

Hi dolls

I am after a new black liquid eye-liner and I thought you might be able to recommend what your favourite eye-liner is for doing the cat eye look?

Thank you : )

 

[Scarlett Lee]

I'm loving Soap and Glory's new supercat liquid liner pen, precision and complete control.  My flicks have never been so perfect!!

[Ashley Rose]

I prefer Merle Norman's Creme eyeliner in black or slate! You apply it with a brush and it just glides right on. It's also waterproof so your perfect cat eye lasts all day  (and then some)!

[Stylemasters Hair Adornments]

I am NOT all fancy about products at all.. so I get the ELF brand from Target for a buck! It lasts long and I use it to create the cat eye, it wipes off easy to make corrections too, I then go over it with Glitter Rocks from Walgreens to KEEP the line there... All in all, $4.00 and it works. Stays on all day and doesn't smudge with normal wear. =)

[Shelley Minson]

I am loving MAC Blacktrack fluidliner, thanks again for all your suggestions! xox

[Secrets of a Pinup Skin Care]

My super fave is Stila Smudge Pot eye liner and a fine angled brush. You can get it at sephora. It comes in many colours and one jar lasts forever. I've tried many other things but I keep coming back to it. It makes crisp lines but can also be smoaked out if needed. I hope you find the perfect liner. When you do... let us know :) 

[MothraGirl]

I love Makeup Forever cake liner! Been using it for years.

[Scarlett_Rose]

I vote MAC Blacktrack Fluidline eyeliner too :o) Definitely worth paying extra for because it lasts!

[Bettie B Dangerous Swimwear]

I really like the liquid pen liner
In " Trooper" by Kat von D. That stuff
Will stay on in the shower n pool n sweat!!
5 Stars!!
Xoxo
Nikki

[Santi]

I've used MAC Blacktrack Fluidline for YEARS and I LOVE it to bits. Smooth, easy application and lasts.

[SoozeeVicious]

My favorite is Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Perversion, it's more of a splurge, but it looks great and lasts all day. The fine brush is PERFECT.

[Miss Kiki Berlin]

I like to use pen liner since I have a slight stigma in my right eye. After trying quite a few, I was introduced to Hourglass'  "Calligraphy" Pen Liner. The precision is impeccable and the density is easily build-able. It literally can go from looking like a smudge pot to liquid liner. The pen tip NEVER frays/separates. It lasts day into night and washes completely off my sensitive skin w/Dove soap and water. You should be able to get it at Sephora. Hopefully, this at least helps someone =D

[kaytwitha_y]

What I like to use is something that will dry and stay dark. I also am on a very strict budget. I go for whatever liquid liner I can find and I will normally wait for each layer to dry so I can get the desired dark color I want. :)